Remembering Mets History (1986) NLCS Game #1 Mike Scott Outduels Dwight Gooden 1-0 in Opener



October 8th 1986: NLCS Game #1 Houston, Texas: The NLCS opened up with much excitement for the Mets & their fans. It had been 13 long years since the Mets last NLCS appearance when they beat the mighty Big Red Machine to advance to the teams second World Series.

NL East Champs: The 1986 Mets NL Eastern Champs had dominated their division staying in first place all year long & finishing up 21.5 games ahead of the second place Phillies. 

The Mets put up a franchise record 108 wins the most in the major leagues. They had finished with the leagues best batting average (.263) & most runs scored (783) while hitting 148 HRs. Their pitching staff led in wins (108) & ERA (3.11).

NL West Champs: The Western Division Champion Astros, led by manager Hal Lanier had won 96 games, ten games ahead of the Cincinnati Reds winning the franchise second divisional title. The Astros were led by pitching, second to the Mets in wins (96) ERA (3.15), tops in the league in strike outs (1160) shut outs (11) & saves (51) with the Mets right behind them second in two of the three categories.

Offensively the Astros scored just 654 runs below the league average & eight in a field of twelve.
They hit .255 but did have speed stealing 163 bases 45 more as a team than New York.

The series opened up in Houston, as 44,131 came to the legendary Astrodome which at one time had been labeled "the eighth wonder of the world" as the first indoor ball park. Two of the games top pitchers went at it as Dwight Gooden went up against Mike Scott as it was Doctor against doctor. Dr K against the master of doctoring baseballs.

Gooden coming off his amazing 1985 Cy Young season, had gone 17-6 with a 2.84 ERA notching 200 strike outs. From August 1st, Gooden had won seven of his last nine decision's (7-2) with a 2.66 ERA & had pitched a complete game the night New York clinched the NL East.

On the mound for Houston was Mike Scott. Scott began his career with the Mets (1979-1982) going 14-27 with a 4.64 ERA getting traded to the Astros for Dany Heep.

Mike Scott learned to throw the split finger fast ball from the "guru of the split finger" Roger Craig. By 1985 Scott's career turned around as he put up a back to back 18 win seasons.

1986 Cy Young Winner: In 1986 Scott led the NL in ERA (2.22) Strike outs (306) shut outs (5) WAR (8.4) & innings (275) winning the CY Young Award, making his first All Star team & pitching a no-hitter the night Houston clinched the NL West.

But Scott's success became very controversial as he had been publicly accused of doctoring or scuffing up baseballs by Giants manager Roger Craig as well as Cubs manager Jim Frey. 

Scuff would be one of the biggest stories of this NLCS as he became known as "Mike Scuff" with Mets payers accusing him of scuffing the baseball. No doubt he had major success in the series, either by cheating, split finger fastballs or just getting into the Mets heads.

Texan & Vice President of the United States George Bush threw out the ceremonial first pitch. ABC Sports carried the series with Keith Jackson & Tim McCarver covering the action. At the time Tim McCarver was a regular season broadcaster for the Mets.

In the top of the 1st inning Len Dykstra attempted a bunt base hit to start the game but was unsuccessful. Wally Backman reached on a Bill Doran error but Mike Scott then struck out Keith Hernandez & Gary Carter to end the inning. 

After the first pitch to  him, Gary Carter asked home plate umpire Doug Harvey to check the baseball. Harvey's inspection proved satisfactory. Keith Hernandez & Ray Knight would also ask Harvey to inspect baseballs on the night.

In the bottom of the 1st inning Dwight Gooden retired the side in order on three fly balls to Jose Cruz in left field. In the bottom of the 2nd, Glenn Davis led off with a HR giving Houston a 1-0 lead in what was to the only run of the game.

Trivia: Glenn Davis was the Astros biggest bat as he was second in the NL with 31 HRs & fourth with 101 RBIs.

The next batter, Kevin Bass doubled, then with one out Gooden walked Alan Ashby & Craig Reynolds singled loading the bases. But Gooden struck out Mike Scott & got Billy Hatcher to ground out to Ray Knight at third base to end the inning.

Mike Scott retired nine Mets in a row until Keith Hernandez 4th inning base hit. Hernandez had

been very successful against Scott in his career batting .377 with six HR & 14 RBIs.

Quotes- Keith Hernandez: "We all know what Mike does, so I prepare for it, that's all".

In the bottom of the 4th, the Astros collected three straight singled off Gooden but Mike Scott hit into an inning ending double play Santana-to Backman-to Hernandez.

In the top of the 5th, Rafael Santana collected the Mets second hit with a single to left field but Dwight Gooden flew out to right to end the inning. 

Scott would not allow another Mets hit until the 8th inning when pinch hitter Danny Heep (the man Scott was traded for) singled with one out. Len Dykstra would reach on an infield single giving the Mets the only time they had more than one base runner in the game.

But Scott then struck out Wally Backman & Keith Hernandez to end the inning.

Dwight Gooden exited after seven innings, down 1-0 he had given up an earned run on seven hits, three walks & five strike outs. Jesse Orosco would come on for a scoreless 8th.

In the top of the 9th, Darryl Strawberry singed collecting the Mets fifth & final hit of the game. Darryl stole second base to put the tying run in scoring position. 

Mookie Wilson then with a ball to the left of first base that Glen Davis dove & smothered, he threw to Scott covering first & Mookie was called out on the close play. Mike Scott struck out Ray Knight for his 14th K of the night to end the game.

Record Tying Strike Out: Mike Scott matched the Pirates John Candeleria who struck out an NLCS record 14 Reds in 1975 surpassing the Mets Tom Seaver's 1973 NLCS Record of 13 Ks.

Scott went the distance edging Dwight Gooden 1-0 pitching the shut out, striking out 14 with five hits & one walk. Keith Hernandez & Gary Carter both went down three times on strikes in the game.

Quotes- Gary Carter: "His pitches had more movement than any balls I've seen all year. The bottom dropped right out of it, there wasn't any rotation on the ball. People feel he uses some substance. I dont know for sure but if he does do it you have to tip your hat to him."

Comments