Trivia: The fiery, passionate shortstop with the quick temper was nicknamed “Crazy Horse” by his fellow team mates. They said he keeps wandering up & down the dugout like an Indian on the warpath. The shy mild looking Foli was notorious for getting into fights with opposing players, umpires & his own team mates as well.
Early on he would throw temper tantrum's & cause trouble if the situation wasn't right. But he was a fierce competitor & hard nosed player that gave it his all. Ed Kranepool noted that Foli was so hyper, he brought his bat back to the hotel room with him.
He was the number one overall draft pick in the 1968 draft, chosen by the New York Mets. Although he was a tough hitter to strikeout, he had little power, not much speed on the bases & didn’t draw many walks.
He was a very good bunter & sacrifice hitter, finishing in the leagues top ten in sacrifice hits eight times. Foli was all about his glove, he was an excellent defensive short stop. His biggest problem above all was the fact the Mets had Bud Harrelson at short as well as veteran Al Weis on the club. Foli's chances of breaking through were slim.
In 1969 while the Mets were on their way to winning the World Series, Foli showed off that glove & hit over .300 for their A ball Visalia club. In 1970 he spent most of the year at AAA Tidewater, hitting .261 getting a cup of coffee in September, making his debut on September 11th 1970.
In his second career game, he had two hits and drove in an 8th inning insurance run as the Mets beat the St. Louis Cardinals.
Drama: Early on in his Mets career (1971) he got into a dugout scuffle with Mets veteran Ed Kranepool. Kranepool believed Foli had been bouncing balls & throwing wide to first base, intentionally during infield practice. Kranepool then threw grounders to all other infielders except Foli & refused to have a pre game warm up toss with him near the dugout.
Foli confronted Kranepool, soon words turned to shoves with Kranepool smacking Foli in the nose before teammates broke it up. Veteran Kranepool said "he was showing me up in front of my team mates & I cant have that."
With that as well as 1971 starting NL All Star- Bud Harrelson at short stop, Foli almost had to beg to see some playing time. He made most of his appearances at second & third base. On May 9, he had one of his biggest offensive games, getting three hits with an RBI triple and a three-run double in a 9-5 win over the St. Louis Cardinals. It would be his only four-RBI game until eight years later in 1979.
In August he had a three RBI day in the second game of an August 3rd double header. The Mets won the game 9-5 beating the reigning World Series Champion Cincinnati Reds. On the last day of the season, he drove in two runs as Tom Seaver beat the St. Louis Cardinals at Shea Stadium for his twentieth victory.
Overall he finished 1971 playing in 97 games, batting .226 with 12 doubles, 32 runs scored and 24 RBIs. In 12 games at his natural short stop position he was perfect, making no errors. He posted a .964 fielding % in 58 games at second base making nine errors & .954 % in 36 games at third.
Just before the 1972 season began, Foli was involved in a huge Mets trade, he along with Ken Singleton and Mike Jorgensen were sent to the Montreal Expos for star outfielder Rusty Staub.
Expos Career: In Montreal, Foli became the Expos main shortstop for the next five seasons, batting between .238 and .264 each year.
Brawl: Foli was a popular player in Montreal, and in a July 1973 game against the Houston Astros the fans showed it. Houston's' Bob Watson slid hard into second base, to break up a double play raising his forearm to Foli. Foli was leveled falling to the ground, bleeding from the mouth, suffering a broken jaw & had to be taken off the field on a stretcher.
When Watson went to left field in the next inning, the Montreal fans at Jarry Park hurled any kind of debris they could find at Watson stopping the game. Foli missed the next month of the season but did make a triumphant return, still playing in 126 games that year. Three days after his return he got suspended for three games for bumping Umpire Ken Burkhart.
Foli was hated by players around the league, in 1974 he got into another scuffle with the Dodgers Rick Auerbach. Dodger players called him a cheap shot artist & a player wh can dish it out but cant take it.
In 1975 he led all NL short stops in games (151) assists (497) put outs (260) & was fourth with a .973 fielding %. One story says Foli spent the whole night sitting on second base at Montreal's Jarry Park after making an error leading to an Expo loss. This was similar to a minor league game where he spent the night sleeping at second base after going 0-5 in a day game.
In 1976 he posted career highs with 36 doubles (5th in the N.L.) HRs (6) and slugging (.366%).
In an April 21st, game, he singled, doubled and tripled against the Chicago Cubs before the game was suspended due to rain. The next day, the game resumed and he hit a HR to complete the first cycle in Montreal Expos history. He was third in fielding that season & in the top five in assists & put outs once again.
Foli remained in Montreal until mid way through the 1977 season, when he was traded to the San Francisco Giants for their short stop Chris Spier. After 104 games as a Giant, rated as the league's fourth best shortstop, his contract was purchased by the New York Mets.
Return to the Mets: In 1978 he returned to a very different Shea Stadium than he had left six years ago. The Mets were in last place and playing to empty crowds to what became known as "Grants Tomb". Foli struggled at the plate, not hitting over the .200 mark until mid June.
On June 5th he doubled in the bottom of the 9th inning off the Dodgers Terry Forster, tying up the game. He then scored the winning run when Doug Flynn reached on an error.
On June 11th he had his own walk off hit, a single off the Pittsburgh Pirates Eddie Whitson, scoring John Stearns. On September 19th he hit his only HR of the year, coming off Tom Bruno in St. Louis. Foli would play in 113 games for manager Joe Torre’s last place Mets, batting .257, hitting one HR with 21 doubles and 27 RBIs.
He posted a .967 fielding%, turning a league leading 78 double plays with second baseman Doug Flynn. Foli made 18 errors in 522 chances in 112 games on the year.
After playing just three games for the Mets in 1979, he was traded to the Pittsburgh Pirates for shortstop Frank Taveras. The trade sent Foli from the worst team in the league to the best team in the league that was on their way to a World Series title.
He set career highs in Pittsburgh in batting average (.288) RBIs (65) runs (70) and hits (153). He only struck out once in every 38 at bats, which the best ratio in baseball. Foli hit well when it counted most, as he compiled a .333 batting average in the 1979 postseason.
Post Season: Pittsburgh went on to sweep the 1979 NLCS, with Foli driving in a run in all three games.
1979 World Series: In the World Series, against the Baltimore Orioles, he had a hit in six of the seven games, with a double, triple, two walks & three RBIs.
In Game #5 with the Pirates down three games to one, Foli scored the tying run and drove in three runs off Cy Young winner Mike Flanagan. He would also score a run in Game #6 against Orioles' Hall of Famer Jim Palmer, as the Pirates won the Worlds Championship.
In the eighties Defensively, Foli led all shortstops in fielding in 1980 & again in 1982. He would also lead the league in double plays & chances twice.
In 1982 he was traded to the Angels, where he was reunited with his old Expo skipper Gene Mauch. When main short stop Rick Burleson went down with injury, Foli took over batting .252 with 56 RBIs as the Angels went on to win the AL Western title. In the 1982 ALCS he only went 2-16 with an RBI hit.
He spent 1983 in California as well, playing more of a back up role now, at the age of 33. He went to the AL New York team in 1984 & then to Pittsburgh again before retiring after the 1985 season.
He closed out his 16 year career playing 1524 games at short (61st all time) turning 1028 double plays (33rd most all time) with a .972 fielding percentage (63rd all time) making 4804 assists (52nd all time) & 2687 put outs (62nd all time).
He batted .251 with 1515 hits, 25 HRs, 241 doubles, 501 RBIs, a .283 on base % &81 stolen bases in 1696 games.
Retirement: After playing he coached with the Texas Rangers, Milwaukee Brewers, Kansas City Royals and then managed in Puerto Rico under General Manager, former Met Felix Millan.
Millan had to fire the quick tempered Foli during the Caribbean World Series claiming he had been disrespectful.
He managed the Kingsport Mets of the Appalachian League in 1998 and spent 1998 to 2000 with the New York Mets organization as an infield and base running coordinator.
He went to the Cincinnati Reds and got into a brawl there with his fellow coach; Ron Oester. Most recently he has worked in the Washington Nationals organization, as manager of the AA Syracuse Chiefs.
Family: Foli lives in Ormond Beach, Florida with his longtime wife of over forty years, Ginette. Ginette was a former Montreal Playboy Bunny, marrying Tim in 1974.
They have five children together. His son Daniel Foli was a minor league pitcher, who spent time in the Mets organization in 2005.